You are the recipient surgeon on call. A DBD donor offer is received for your 54-year-old recipient with hepatocellular carcinoma within transplant criteria. The donor is a 47-year-old with catastrophic intracranial haemorrhage, stable on low-dose noradrenaline, with normal liver biochemistry and a 20-minute period of CPR three days ago. Past history reveals a cutaneous melanoma excised three years ago, reported as Breslow 1.8 mm with a positive sentinel node treated by completion dissection. What is the most appropriate response to this liver offer?
- AAccept — the melanoma was treated with curative intent more than two years ago
- BAccept, but only after a donor PET-CT excludes recurrence
- CDecline the offer because of unacceptable risk of tumour transmission
- DAccept with a plan for prophylactic immunotherapy in the recipient
- EDecline because of the period of CPR
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: C
Melanoma is among the most feared donor-transmitted malignancies: it metastasises early, can recur after long disease-free intervals, and transmitted disease in an immunosuppressed recipient is usually fatal. A node-positive melanoma three years earlier represents an unacceptable transmission risk, and the correct answer is to decline. UK guidance (SaBTO) treats melanoma as an absolute or near-absolute contraindication to donation regardless of apparent cure.
Why the others are wrong: A — disease-free interval does not neutralise melanoma risk; late recurrence a decade or more after excision is well described. B — a normal PET-CT cannot exclude micrometastatic disease and does not change the risk category. D — there is no accepted prophylactic regimen that makes a high-risk donor malignancy transferable. E — a witnessed arrest with 20 minutes of CPR and subsequently normal liver biochemistry is not a contraindication; many such donors yield excellent grafts.
Key point: assess donor malignancy by tumour biology, not by time elapsed — melanoma, choriocarcinoma and most metastatic cancers are contraindications, whereas low-grade CNS tumours and many treated low-risk cancers are not.
Guidelines: SaBTO advice on organs from donors with malignancy; NHSBT deceased donor offering policies on transmissible cancer risk.