A theatre list includes a thyroidectomy, an elective cholecystectomy, a right hemicolectomy and an appendicectomy for a perforated gangrenous appendix with pus. The infection control lead asks the registrar to classify these wounds and state the expected infection rates. Which account is correct?
- AAll surgical wounds carry much the same postoperative infection risk once appropriate antibiotic prophylaxis has been given, whatever the wound classification says
- BA perforated appendix with pus is classified as a 'clean-contaminated' wound
- CProphylactic antibiotics convert a dirty wound into a clean one
- DClean (thyroidectomy, ~1 to 2%), clean-contaminated (elective cholecystectomy), contaminated (spillage), dirty (established pus — the perforated appendix)
- EClean wounds never become infected, so antibiotic prophylaxis is always unnecessary even for implant surgery
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: D
The wound classification is surgery's oldest risk model and still frames antibiotic and closure decisions. Clean: no entry into respiratory, alimentary, genitourinary tracts, no inflammation, asepsis unbroken — thyroidectomy, hernia repair; baseline infection 1 to 2% (rising with patient factors — the diabetes, smoking, obesity themes of the SSI bundle — and justifying prophylaxis only when a prosthesis makes rare infection catastrophic, per the mesh question). Clean-contaminated: a hollow viscus opened in a controlled fashion without unusual spillage — elective cholecystectomy, prepared colorectal resection, gastric and gynaecological surgery; around 5 to 10%, the category where timed antibiotic prophylaxis earns most of its living. Contaminated: gross gastrointestinal spillage, entry through acutely inflamed non-purulent tissue, major breaks in technique, and fresh ( Why the others are wrong: A, B, C and E — risk is class-dependent; pus makes a wound dirty by definition; antibiotics reduce but never reclassify risk; clean wounds still infect at low rates, and prosthetic implants justify prophylaxis there. Key point: Clean (~1–2%), clean-contaminated (~5–10%), contaminated (~15–20%), dirty (~30–40%): the class predicts SSI, decides prophylaxis (single timed dose) versus treatment (continued course), and steers closure strategy — and a case can be upgraded by what happens on the table. Guidelines: CDC/NHSN surgical wound classification, applied in NICE surgical site infection guidance (NG125): clean, clean-contaminated, contaminated and dirty classes predict infection risk and determine antibiotic prophylaxis versus treatment.