An anaesthetist explains to a surgical trainee why a fluid bolus increased one patient's cardiac output but not another's, using the Frank-Starling relationship. Which account of the determinants of cardiac output is correct?
- ACardiac output depends only on heart rate
- BThe Frank-Starling law of the heart states that a progressively stretched ventricle always contracts more and more weakly with each additional increment of stretch
- CAfterload and preload are the same quantity measured at different times
- DOutput = rate × stroke volume; stroke volume depends on preload (Starling), afterload and contractility — only the steep part of the curve responds to fluid
- EContractility can only be increased by giving intravenous fluid
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: D
Cardiac output (~5 L/min at rest) is the product of rate and stroke volume, and stroke volume's three determinants organise every haemodynamic decision in theatre and intensive care. Preload — the ventricular end-diastolic volume or wall stretch — sets the starting sarcomere length: the Frank-Starling mechanism means greater diastolic filling generates greater force of contraction (length-tension optimisation of actin-myosin overlap plus length-dependent calcium sensitivity), so the heart automatically ejects what it receives, matching the two ventricles' outputs beat by beat. The curve's shape carries the clinical meaning: on its steep ascending limb, volume raises output — the fluid-responsive patient; on the plateau, further filling adds only congestion — the physiology formalised by the passive leg raise and stroke-volume-variation testing in this bank's critical care section. Afterload — the load resisting ejection, approximated by systemic vascular resistance and aortic impedance — inversely affects stroke volume, most punishingly in the failing ventricle (why vasodilators help cardiogenic failure and why cross-clamping the aorta stresses the heart). Contractility — the inotropic state at any given load, set by sympathetic drive, calcium handling and drugs (catecholamines up; acidosis, hypoxia, beta-blockade down) — shifts the whole curve up or down: the failing septic or ischaemic heart operates on a flattened, downshifted curve, the rationale for inotropes when volume and pressure are optimised but output is not.
Why the others are wrong: A, B, C and E — stroke volume matters as much as rate; Starling describes stronger contraction with (physiological) stretch; pre- and afterload are distinct loading conditions; contractility is load-independent and drug- or state-modified, not fluid-modified.
Key point: Output = rate × stroke volume; stroke volume = preload (Starling's steep limb vs plateau — the whole basis of fluid-responsiveness testing), afterload (resistance to ejection) and contractility (the curve's position) — locate the patient on the curve before choosing fluid, vasopressor or inotrope.